Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (2/4 Hats)




Adam Says Hats Off:

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story: Don’t Be A Menace To Society While Stealing Plans In The Hood. Rating as follows:

Cinematography (2): 1.3
Overall Acting (1.9): 1.3
Story Telling (1.7): 1.4
Cohesion of Story (1.4): 1.1
Score/Sound Mixing (1.1): 1.1
Depth of Plot (1): 0.7
Character Dev (0.5): 0.3
Overall Message (0.4): 0.2

Total: 7.4/10

There’s an audience in mind when they make these films, and they delivered. This was a great connection between the 3rd and 4th episodes and provided a great addition to the Star Wars family. They did a great job with the ending, which was really fun to watch. Sure, the characters weren’t super deep and yes you don’t openly see what all their motives are, but I didn’t really need to know everything. The cinematography was average to me, but still provided some awesome moments on screen. In general, they told the story well and entertained their target audience. Worth seeing in theaters for sure!



Austinn Says Hats Off:

‘Rogue One: A Star Wars Story’: Erso They Say. conclusion: 8/10. The movie is cheesy and predictable in certain instances, but there were a lot of things I really loved. The score was good, the cinematography and action sequences were done well, the ending was bold and it also lined up super well with Episode 4. The robot character was actually good, and quite charming, not too silly; nothing like that garbage heap C3PO. Overall a fun film. No doubt, however, the best parts of the movie were the scenes with Darth Vader! So freaking awesome!! #empirestateofmind #GrandmaTarkin#theforceisstronginmyframily#blasteribarelyknowher #noarmswerecutoffinthemakingofthisfilm#Vadersgonnahate



Kelvin Kept His Hat On:

“Rogue One: The Emipre’s New Groove.” Conclusion: 5/10. I know the sentimentalism and nostalgia is enough for some and that’s all well and good, but this movie really isn’t. It’s fine, but as far as character development goes and even my suspension of disbelief, the film was rather lacking. The characters were pretty shallow and one dimensional and the motivations of many weren’t even addressed. As for the humor, some of it was genuinely funny but I found myself far too often groaning at the self-reference or rehashing of old jokes. While the plot was certainly more creative when compared with Episode VII, I found it hampered by the uninteresting characters and some pretty convenient and unbelievable moments, even given the normal suspension of disbelief. I’m sure many will be willing to overlook the movie’s deficiencies but I simply could not. #IFoughtTheRogueAndTheRogueOne #DadsMikkelsel #MyWipeLeftMe #TheMonMothmaStory #LaterVader #ConvenienceStory #ConscientiousDefector #TheSawShankDefection #OrsonTells



Jarrod Kept His Hat On:

#83 Film in 2016: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story 6.5/10 So I have pretty mixed feelings on this film. First off, this is a better film than The Force Awakens due to a much stronger storyline and less plot holes. However, The Force Awakens is a more fun, enjoyable film with better characters. So although this is a higher quality film, I would much rather watch The Force Awakens, despite its massive flaws (if you want to go to My Notes back a year ago, you can read my lengthy review of why The Force Awakens has so many problems). Here is what I liked about Rogue One: I loved how they tied the story into A New Hope perfectly and actually strengthened A New Hope in terms of giving the Death Star a solid reason for its flaw. I have heard mixed responses on the score but for it being a non-John Williams score, I personally thought they did a solid job with how little time they had to score it, despite not having a memorable theme. I liked the action scenes and the majority of the special effects. I liked the ballsy ending that is extremely rare for a blockbuster to have and I do like that the characters were more average Joes as opposed to being “Chosen Ones” who were destined for greatness. This film has quite a few problems though. The characters were underdeveloped and therefore I didn’t care for the vast majority of them at all, I had trouble understanding some of Forest Whitaker and Diego Luna’s dialogue due to either them slurring their lines or having too thick of an accent. The blind character was probably the most annoying thing about the film. I didn’t believe for a second that he could do the things he could do. He was way over the top. The CGI Grand Moff Tarkin looked so distractingly fake that it took me out of the film, especially when he stood next to real life humans. Plus, they had a lot of close ups on his face which was not a smart idea. Darth Vader was a pro and a con. He was the coolest/most badass part of the film but that is also a con because when you are trying to establish new characters you probably don’t want the best part of your film to be an older character who overshadows all your new ones in two minutes of screen time. I could go into more details about plot holes (the squid monster thing who is supposed to read minds but apparently just didn’t because Forest Whitaker still didn’t know if the defector was telling the truth or not?) but I don’t want to get into spoiler territory. Feel free to message or call me if you want to talk more specifics or spoilery content regarding the film. It is worth seeing but I am still waiting for a great Star Wars film to come out in my life time. This could have been so much better.
#AnotherOneBitesTheDust / #SuicideSquad / #JynAndJuice / #SaveTheRebellionSaveTheDreamSaveTheCheerleaderSaveTheWorld / #TarkinToTheMoon / #SchizoKrennic

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s